Another Day, Another Decision Shows Fighting Visa Cancellation Is Hard!
As we have seen over the last year, the Minister has been (very) actively using the powers given under the Act to personally cancel the visas of non-citizens who have committed serious criminal offences and who, as a result, do not pass the character test.
And recent decisions from the Full Court in the cases of Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Eden have forcefully brought home the fact that the potential grounds for challenging a cancellation decision are really quite narrow, and thus the prospects for success in contesting a cancellation are commensurately “poor”.
In both Stretton and in Eden, the Full Court reversed decisions by Judge Logan of the Federal Circuit Court in Queensland where His Honour had ruled that the visa cancellations were essentially “disproportionate” and therefore “legally unreasonable”. Judge Logan had used a pithy analogy in describing those Ministerial decisions, equating the visa cancellations to “using a sledgehammer to crack a nut”.
...