My Christmas present to you! [Imagine a world where there is a finding that the Caveats are INVALID!]

Imagine this scenario....Your client made an application for a 457 before 17 April 2017 and it was refused and you are on appeal at the AAT.
The substantive issue was an assertion by DOHA that the position was not genuine.
However, you are now at the AAT and you are winning on the genuine position issue and then the Tribunal ambushes you by saying words to the effect, '...however, notwithstanding that the subject position is genuine it is subject to a caveat and you do not meet that requirement."
...